1plus2
  • Début
  • Aperçu
  • Blog
  • Anfang
  • Übersicht
  • Blog
  • Home
  • Overview
  • Blog

God's Spirit and Regeneration

    Jesus answered and said to him, ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.’ John 3:3

The translation ‘born again’ is incorrect. The Greek text does not contain the term ‘born again’. It is based on the church dogma that humans do not have the spirit of God and that, just as their flesh was born of a woman, their spirit must also be born of the Spirit. Literally translated, Jesus says: ‘Unless someone is born from above’. This is not about a new birth, but quite simply a birth. Humans must be born from above; they do not need to be born again. This sentence was addressed to Nicodemus, a learned Pharisee whom Jesus refers to in verse 10 as a ‘the teacher of Israel’. So where does the idea that humans must be born again come from? Let us read the text (John 3:3-10):

Jesus answered and said to him, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God.” Nicodemus said to Him, “How can a man be born when he is old? He cannot enter a second time into his mother’s womb and be born, can he?” Jesus answered, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless one is born of water and the Spirit (πνεῦμα) he cannot enter into the kingdom of God. “That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the Spirit (πνεῦμα) is spirit (πνεῦμα). “Do not be amazed that I said to you, ‘You must be born again.’ “The wind (πνεῦμα) blows where it wishes and you hear the sound of it, but do not know where it comes from and where it is going; so is everyone who is born of the Spirit (πνεῦμα).” Nicodemus said to Him, “How can these things be?” Jesus answered and said to him, “Are you the teacher of Israel and do not understand these things?
Let us first note that the Greek term πνεῦμα pneuma is translated first as ‘spirit’ and then as ‘wind’. As we shall see later, the term ‘spirit’ has many meanings. At this stage, let us simply bear in mind that comparing the Spirit of God to the wind is a poor analogy if the Spirit is a person of the Trinity. But the image would be far more meaningful if the Spirit of God were an essence, reflecting the nature of God. Jesus is surprised that a scholar like Nicodemus does not understand what he is talking about. His question about whether one must return to his mother's womb to be born again was meant rhetorically. He wanted to say precisely that it is not possible to be born a second time. The idea of rebirth is absurd, and Jesus could not understand how a scholar could not know something that is so obvious throughout the Old Testament. The Church has taken up an absurd idea based on a rhetorical question whose answer was obviously negative. Take a deep breath, pause and reflect. Jesus' astonishment is based on something that is easy to verify. His words were absolutely nothing new, because anyone who was supposed to know the Old Testament should have known this easily. Tell me, where in the Old Testament is rebirth mentioned? I remember my old role model, the professor of theology, master of fidelity to the Word of God, mocking Nicodemus from the pulpit. I sat in the congregation and had to laugh too. But for years I kept asking myself the same question: Where in the Old Testament is rebirth mentioned so clearly that Jesus has to marvel at the ignorance of a learned Pharisee? Since I had attended Bible school, I should have been able to answer such a basic question easily. The answer is simple: rebirth is not mentioned, not even once.
Let us return to the point: we have seen that St Augustine assumed precisely that human beings no longer had a spirit. By linking John 3:3 to this idea, Augustine concluded that human beings were spiritually dead at birth and therefore needed to be reborn. A physical birth and a spiritual birth. We have also seen that according to Genesis 6:3, every human being has the spirit of God, even the wicked. In fact, human beings die without the spirit of God. Incidentally, it is equally easy to prove that human beings also have a spirit, for example here (Zech 12:1):

‘The burden of the word of the Lord concerning Israel. Thus declares the Lord who stretches out the heavens, lays the foundation of the earth, and forms the spirit of man within him.​​’

The meaning of the term ‘spirit’

The Old Testament is written almost exclusively in Hebrew, while the New Testament is written entirely in Greek. In both languages, the term spirit (רוּחַ ruach in Hebrew and πνεῦμα pneuma in Greek) is a very vague concept, but their meanings generally overlap. Thus, the Greek translation (LXX) of the Old Testament usually translates ruach (‘spirit’ in Hebrew) as pneuma (‘spirit’ in Greek). However, depending on the context, ‘spirit’ can have different meanings, as the following (incomplete) list shows:
Picture
A table illustrating some of the various meanings of the word ‘spirit’ in both Hebrew and Greek.
Proverbs 7:8 illustrates how the Spirit was understood. Translated literally, the second part of the verse reads ‘better a length of spirit than a height of spirit’. The NIV translates this as ‘patience is better than pride’. Patience and haughtiness describe invisible qualities. Why would God’s Spirit not refer to God’s invisible qualities, to His very nature? It suffices to go through these Bible verses and compare them in different translations to become aware of the diversity conveyed by the term ‘spirit’. I will content myself here with citing just one Bible passage as an illustrative example. The list is by no means complete, as this is a word that is frequently used in the Bible.
So how is it that in the New Testament the term ‘spirit’ suddenly becomes a person? In the first centuries of church history, the Spirit of God thus took on a very specific meaning: the Spirit of God is a person of the Trinity: Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Why? Because the Spirit repeatedly exhibits the characteristics of a person. One can lie to him (Acts 5:3), tempt him (Acts 5:9), grieve him (Eph 4:30), he guides (Luke 4:1), he teaches (John 16:12), etc. But it's not that simple. Revelation speaks of the seven spirits of God (3:1, etc.). Should I write ‘the seven spirits’ with a capital or small letter now? However, we must not forget that it is not only the Spirit of God who has the characteristics of a person. The wisdom of God also has them. She calls (Prov 8:1), she stands up (Prov 8:2), she has something to say and teaches the right way (Prov 8:6), she possesses counsel and success (Prov 8:14) and she builds her house (Prov 9:1). Job 28 speaks of this in similar terms. I give these examples only for illustration and have no intention of compiling a complete list. If the church hadn’t formatted my mind to Trinity, looking back now I can’t see how I could reduce God to a triune entity. Does God consist of three persons? Only three? I dare to doubt that. In Hebrew, the term Elohim (God) is almost always in the plural, but the verbs are often in the singular. Incidentally, the term ‘Trinity’ is not used anywhere in the Bible, and nowhere in the New Testament is it explained that God is a unity of three persons. Throughout church history, several people have pointed this out, sometimes at the cost of their lives. Why am I saying all this? For whilst the Spirit of God sometimes possesses the attributes of a person, at other times it does not: It is poured out (Isaiah 44:3), one can be filled with it (Eph 5:18), it is a power (Acts 1:18), etc. For years I have wondered how I can be filled with the Holy Spirit. For if it is a person, either I have it or I do not. Let us take the opposite example: the New Testament regularly speaks of possessed people. One can be possessed by a demon (Matthew 15:22), one can be possessed by several demons (Mark 5:9), one can be possessed by a somewhat evil demon or by more evil demons (Luke 11:16), but never is a person possessed by a demon to a lesser or greater degree. How does this same Spirit operate in such a diffuse manner that there are Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and Protestant churches? If the Spirit of God is a person, how is it that the right wing of the evangelical movement fights against the left wing, and vice versa? At the time, the answer seemed simple to me. The others do not have the Holy Spirit, or only a little of it. However, I could not resolve the following problem: How can someone have only a quarter or a tenth of a person? How is it that some half-hearted Christians barely reach 12.34 per cent, whilst others are so overflowing with the Spirit of God that even the apostle Paul would be jealous? Could it be that the authors of the New Testament had a more comprehensive concept in mind than just a person when they used the term ‘spirit’? The Spirit of God is a supernatural concept: love, faithfulness, loyalty, mercy, etc. are all metaphysical concepts, genuine forces. So if the Spirit of God refers to the very nature of God, it is entirely possible to be shaped by it to a greater or lesser extent. Suddenly, the fullness of the Holy Spirit makes sense.
The New Testament uses the term ‘flesh’ to refer to our physical body. Through our five senses (sight, smell, taste, hearing and touch), we perceive the world in which we live. It is through our flesh, our body, that we are able to interact with the visible world. The spirit, on the other hand, is the means by which we perceive intangible things, such as love, hope, faith and perseverance, but also hatred, shame and so on. If you give love to a stone, it will not return it, for a stone has no spirit; it can therefore neither receive nor give love. Just as certain sensors can detect ultraviolet light, which is invisible to the naked eye, our minds enable us to perceive metaphysical dimensions. Our spirit is not a ‘one-way channel’ only, but allows for two-way communication. Here is an illustration:
Picture
An illustration of what distinguishes the flesh from the spirit.
The theory of evolution primarily seeks to explain everything in the visible world – biology, biochemistry and so on. My faith is too small to believe in it. 
In my book, I will explain what the soul is, from a biblical perspective. As for faith and the knowledge of good and evil, I discuss these on the next page, ‘Faith’. On this page, I’m going to dwell a little longer on the spirit. I remember an elderly man who told me one day that he’d had an argument with his wife. After their argument, their daughter came in from outside into the living room where they were sitting. She hadn’t heard the argument, but as she walked in, she remarked: ‘What a shitty atmosphere!’ The old gentleman’s point was that we sometimes sense things that are neither spoken, nor expressed, nor visible. It is precisely through our spirit that we perceive them.
​It is worth noting here that, at the resurrection, we will have a spiritual body. Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 15:42–44:

‘So also is the resurrection of the dead. It is sown perishable body, it is raised can imperishable body; it is sown in dishonor, it is raised in glory; it is sown in weakness, it is raised in power; it is sown a natural body, it is raised a spiritual body.’
​What NAS translates here as ‘natural body’ is literally ‘psychic body’. ψυχικός (psychic) is the adjective form of ψυχή (psyche >> soul). Our physical body is therefore psychic; in other words, it is the expression of our soul. As I have already mentioned, in my book I shall elaborate on what the soul is from a biblical perspective. In a nutshell: just as our physical body shares its essence with our soul (our psyche), so our resurrected body will be an expression of our spirit; it will be spiritual.
What distinguishes the letter of the law from its spirit is touched upon here:

‘But now we have been released from the Law, having died to that by which we were bound, so that we serve in newness of the spirit and not in oldness of the letter.’ Romans 7:6
I think the following example illustrates the difference between the letter and the spirit of the law. Hillel, the most prominent Pharisee of his time, died when Jesus was a teenager. During Hillel's lifetime and even after his death, his most bitter rival was Shammai. Hillel had been president of the Sanhedrin, the high court of Israel, and Shammai—originally vice-president—succeeded him after his death. There were many disputes between them, including one about divorce. However, to illustrate the difference between the letter and the spirit of the law, I will use another dispute as an example: during the Feast of Tabernacles, one of the three major Jewish festivals, Moses had decreed that the entire people should live in huts for a week. These were temporary leaf booths. This festival was intended to commemorate the exodus from Egypt, because when the Hebrews were finally driven out by Pharaoh, they lived in temporary huts. The reason given by Moses was (Leviticus 23:43): ‘So that your generations may know that I had the sons of Israel live in booths when I brought them out from the land of Egypt.’ When his daughter-in-law gave birth to her child during this festival, Shammai – the strict Pharisee – opened the roof of her room to cover it with branches for fear of violating this law. Shammai required all people to live in huts. He also forbade the booths from being kept from one year to the next. ‘You shall rejoice before the Lord your God for seven days,’ Moses had commanded the Hebrews for this festival, ‘you shall suffer under your yoke when you are sick,’ Shammai turned it into. Hillel, on the other hand, made reasonable exceptions for children and the sick and had no objection to the materials for a hut being kept from year to year. You see, for Shammai, the law concerning the Feast of Tabernacles was an end in itself. Hillel, on the other hand, understood that the spirit of the law was not to make the sick even sicker, but that a healthy person should remember the liberation from slavery in Egypt and rejoice in it.
This example illustrates the problem with the law: one can violate the spirit of God's law in order to obey its letter.
Have you ever considered the fact that, in the Ten Commandments, God tells us what we must not do? The Ten Commandments do not tell us what we must do; they teach us what we must give up. However, a person who possesses the essence of God (I am using this term as a synonym for ‘spirit’) has no need for laws, because they will intuitively (guided by the spirit) do what the law is meant to illustrate.

The spirit in the Old Testament

What all the prophets of the Old Testament have in common, what Nicodemus should have known without thinking, is summarised in the following passage (Zechariah 7:8-12a):

‘Then the word of the Lord came to Zechariah saying, “Thus has the Lord of hosts said, ‘Dispense true justice and practice kindness and compassion each to his brother; and do not oppress the widow or the orphan, the stranger or the poor; and do not devise evil in your hearts against one another.’ But they refused to pay attention and turned a stubborn shoulder and stopped their ears from hearing. They made their hearts like flint so that they could not hear the law and the words which the Lord of hosts had sent by His Spirit through the former prophets.​​’
There are many such passages in the Old Testament. Please tell me where in the Bible a prophet accuses Israel of being unspiritual because they had not offered enough sacrifices? Animal sacrifices illustrated the principle of substitution, but had no spiritual value in themselves whatsoever. That is why there is no prophet who complains about a lack of offerings and animal sacrifices, unspiritual music or overly boisterous festivals. On the contrary (Amos 5:21–24):

‘I hate, I reject your festivals, nor do I delight in your solemn assemblies. Even though you offer up to Me burnt offerings and your grain offerings, I will not accept them; And I will not even look at the peace offerings of your fatlings. Take away from Me the noise of your songs; I will not even listen to the sound of your harps. But let justice roll down like waters and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream.​’
It wasn’t the sacrifices, the ceremonies or the music that was too loud that were the problem (after all, it was God who had demanded this of them). What he held against Israel was hypocrisy: to put it in modern terms: going to church on Sundays, acting all pious and singing lovely ‘Hallelujah’ songs, and then, on weekdays, exploiting workers and taking one’s own family members to court over inheritance disputes. And while the law regulated rituals, sacrifices and purification rites, its spirit never had anything other than morality in mind. In a specific context, the law of Moses was intended to express the will, nature and spirit of God. Animal sacrifices and purification laws had an educational purpose. At the time of Jesus, however, there were many religious leaders who had made the law an end in itself. I repeat: the law was never about religion, but always about ethics. The spirit of God is not concerned with musical style, liturgy or religious matters (whether Jewish, Muslim, Christian or otherwise); the spirit of God is concerned with ethics. If your religious convictions lead you to commit acts of terrorism, you have renounced the spirit of God. Alexander Jannaeus, one of the last Hasmoneans to hold the offices of both high priest and king, had eight hundred Pharisees crucified in the very heart of Jerusalem, because they had sought the aid of the Seleucids to overthrow him. (According to Jewish law, these two offices could not be held by the same person: the king had to be a descendant of David, and the high priest a descendant of Aaron). He then had their wives and children slaughtered before their very eyes, whilst he lay, a cup in his hand, surrounded by his concubines. But there were also fanatical Jews (the Sicarii) who in turn massacred their fellow countrymen. Like today’s suicide bombers, these assassins combined brutality with the element of surprise. Their knives earned them a certain reputation on the streets and no doubt enabled unscrupulous leaders to demand ‘protection’ from wealthy targets. As is the case today, their revolutionary charisma attracted young people and the unemployed, as well as religious fanatics; it also served as a cover for thieves and extortionists. Their groups were united solely by the desire to overthrow the ruling junta and usurp its powers. In a nutshell: terrorism was not invented in the twentieth century. In my youth, I used to fear for my salvation whenever, lost in thought in the supermarket, I failed to notice an apple in my bag and did not pay for it at the till. The ‘sanctification without which no one will see the Lord’ (Heb. 12:14) was deeply engraved upon my obedient soul. If we had to walk past people who had been crucified and were dying a brutal death (a common practice in the Roman Empire) whilst out shopping, or if, like Timothy in Ephesus, we had to pass children being offered for sale as slaves in the market, fanatical Bible-believing hardcore theologians would probably be preoccupied with other matters on a Sunday than lipstick or an unpaid-for apple in the supermarket. The Hebrew term for ‘holiness’ is derived from קָדוֹשׁ (qadosh) and literally means ‘to be set apart’ (cf. Lev 19:2). ‘Set apart’ from what, exactly? No one in the Church ever really explained this to me:
Picture
If you do not belong to a terrorist organisation and lead a decent, normal life, then you belong in the illustration on the right.

The Spirit in the New Testament

The Apostle Paul put it this way (Galatians 5:22–23):

‘But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control; against such things there is no law.​​’

The ultimate aim of the law is the fruit of the Spirit. Here is a Bible verse that has troubled me for years (Romans 8:16):

‘The Spirit himself confirms to our spirit that we are children of God.​​’
The translation quoted here (LEB) is based on the idea that, following rebirth, the Spirit of God (a person) confirms to my spirit that I am a child of God. This idea has occupied my mind for years. From a theological perspective, then, there is a kind of supernatural interaction between God and me. But how can one be certain of this? Now, when translated literally, this text has a different meaning (contrary to many French and German Bible translations, most English Bibles correctly translate as follows):

‘The Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God.​’
Picture
An illustration of the literal meaning of the Greek verb συμμαρτῠρέω (summartureô).
The original meaning of the verb summartureô (συμμαρτῠρέω) is ‘to bear witness together’. It is a verb composed of martureô (to bear witness) and the prefix sun (together), which becomes sum before the letter μ (the equivalent of the letter m in our alphabet). We find this prefix in the Greek word ‘sun-thesis’, meaning a ‘putting things together to form a whole’. See, the magic vanishes into thin air. The German translation Gute Nachricht is revealing. It reads: ‘Thus his Spirit assures us in our innermost being that we are children of God.‘ It translates the Greek term pneuma (Spirit) once with the meaning ‘person’ (his Spirit) and once with the meaning ‘being’ (in our innermost being). Why should the same term have two different meanings in the same sentence? I like the idea that the Spirit is a being, or an essence. As a synonym for spirit, ‘being’ (or essence) in this context might help the Christian reader to understand what Paul meant. Thus, our ‘being’, our ‘innermost self’, our ‘spirit’ either confirms that we are children of God (provided we bear the fruits of the Spirit), or it refutes it, for example if we were willing to walk over dead corpses to gain or retain power. In my life, I have met several Christians who doubted their salvation precisely because they did not feel this metaphysical miracle—that the Spirit of God testifies to our spirit that we are children of God. In church jargon, this is called ‘assurance of salvation’. The tragedy is that it is usually very sensitive and extremely honest people—who should have the least cause for concern about their status as children of God—who doubt it the most or lack this ‘assurance of salvation’. For those affected, this is a tragedy, and pastors do not know what to do, for this is not a matter of intelligence with which one could reason with sensitive souls, since it is supposedly a spiritual matter. Paul, however, did not describe a metaphysical process accessible only to particularly devout people. He wanted to assure his readers that this was something that was extremely easy to verify. Indeed (Rom 8:9b):

‘But if anyone does not have the spirit of Christ, he does not belong to Him.’

It's so simple that even a child can understand it!

The Book of Life

If you have read the Bible carefully, you may have noticed that the Book of Life, from which people can be blotted out, is mentioned as early as the Old Testament. The first reference to it is found in the book of Exodus, where, following the incident of the golden calf in Exodus 32:32, Moses asked God to blot him out of the Book of Life instead of the idol-worshippers – a request that was not granted. The Book of Life is also mentioned in Psalm 69:28:

‘May they be blotted out of the book of life and may they not be recorded with the righteous.’
This idea also recurs in the New Testament, for example in Revelation 3:5. Have you ever wondered why people can never be written into the Book of Life, but can only be blotted out of it? People do not have to do anything to go to heaven; they have to do something to go to hell!

Salvation (to be saved)

A mission I know well has adopted 1 Timothy 2:4 as its motto:

‘God... desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth.’
However, in evangelical circles it is understood and interpreted as follows:

‘God wants all people to come to the knowledge of the truth and (thereby) be saved.​’

The order of the verse is reversed. Salvation is interpreted as the result of recognising the truth. First one recognises sin, repents, believes as one ought to (with all that this may entail, depending on the church), and (only) then is one saved. In ecclesiastical circles, faith is seen as a set of requirements, a program (comprising devotional practices and creeds that vary from one movement to another) that must be followed in order to be saved. However, biblically speaking, knowledge of the truth is not a prerequisite for salvation; having the Spirit of God is. Thus there are many passages in the Bible to which 2,000 years of church history have imparted a distinctly ecclesiastical flavour. Here are a few further examples: Paul opens the 8th chapter of the Epistle to the Romans with the following words:

‘There is therefore now no condemnation to them that are in Christ Jesus.​​’
The Church goes on to say: ‘So there is only damnation for everyone else’. John 3:16-18

‘For God so loved the world, that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him shall not perish, but have eternal life. For God did not send the Son into the world to judge the world, but that the world might be saved through Him. He who believes in Him is not judged; he who does not believe has been judged already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.’

I will go into more detail on this in my book. By way of a brief summary, let us take a closer look at the meaning of three verbs in their original language, Greek:
  • Apollumi – according to KJV, ‘to perish’
  • Krinô – according to KJV, ‘to condemn’
  • Sôzô – according to KJV, ‘to save’
In John 3:16–17, the three verbs imply that human beings are currently neither ‘lost’ nor ‘judged’, but simply ‘living’. Then, surprisingly, the perspective shifts in verse 18, and human beings are – because of their unbelief – ‘already judged’. This sits poorly with the church’s assumption that man is spiritually dead by nature. Please explain to me how you can judge someone who is not only dead, but who, moreover, never even lived? I was always taught that I was born dead with a black soul and that I must be spiritually reborn through faith, conversion and new birth in order to receive a snow-white heart. In John 3:16–18, however, Jesus reverses this order. Man is not born dead in order to be born again through faith, but he lives in order to be ‘judged’ because of his lack of faith. So that ‘whoever believes in him may not perish’, we read in John 3:16. The verb apollumi used here essentially means ‘to lose one’s life’. According to John 3:16, therefore, humans come into the world ‘alive’, spiritually speaking, for only living people can lose their lives. Let us consider the term sôzô, which theologians often translate as ‘save’ (it also means ‘heal’), but which presupposes that one is alive. I cannot save a dead person; I would have to revive him or her. According to Augustine, even more would be required: since one is spiritually dead, one must receive the breath of life in order to live for the first time. In other words, a new birth, except that neither ‘new’ nor ‘again’ appears in the Greek text. However, since Jesus could speak of nothing other than a new birth, our Bibles add what is obviously missing. Human beings were created in God’s image. Every person has God’s Spirit. But not everyone lives in accordance with it. Tyrants such as Hitler or Stalin do everything in their power to stifle the Spirit of God. What Jesus tells Nicodemus is quite simple: only those whose lives are inspired ‘from above’ (i.e. by goodness) can see the Kingdom of God. He thereby excludes those whose lives are oriented ‘downwards’ (i.e. towards evil). In Judaism, the spirit of God has never been a person. So how and when did it become a member of the Trinity? The answer is simple: three and a half centuries after the death of Jesus!
It was not until the end of the 4th century, at the First Council of Constantinople (381 AD), that the Holy Spirit was elevated to the status of a person of the Trinity.
It is interesting to think outside the box to discover how the Spirit of God is understood in Judaism. Rabbi Rachel Timoner writes in her book Breath of Life, God as Spirit in Judaism about a person who has the spirit of God: ‘there is something extraordinary about him related to the quantity or quality of spirit within him.’ Speaking of Joshua, who possessed the spirit of God and whom Moses appointed as his successor by the laying on of hands (Num. 27:18), she adds: ‘Today, we would probably call him charismatic’. Among the Jews, having the spirit of God is not a matter of salvation; it is a matter of gift, of charisma, an extraordinary capacity for leadership or a specific task. 
As a overview, let's turn to the final missing piece: Faith! 
Faith

By Chris Zürcher. Page updated on 1 November 2026
By Chris Zürcher. Site updated on 6 November 2026
​​© 2026 www.1plus2.info
Picture
Picture
  • Début
  • Aperçu
  • Blog
  • Anfang
  • Übersicht
  • Blog
  • Home
  • Overview
  • Blog